www.melanexjou.fora.pl

[uuboot76]

Badge of courtyard of disuse of the Imperial Palace of one stylist requirement, the Imperial Palace says to never be divulged participate plan
This year on July 18, museum of the Imperial Palace announced courtyard badge design. Although blueprint of 2788 courtyards badge was collected to stalk of grain in the whole nation before this [link widoczny dla zalogowanych], but enter small hole of law of the Imperial Palace without. Final, the courtyard badge that the Imperial Palace announces, the graph that is the firm of a design that selects separately stalks of grain.

Yesterday, ever stalked of grain him blueprint the design of industry of Anhui industry university that casts the Imperial Palace fastens Yue Lai of director Zhu Yan to Beijing, mix the Imperial Palace be chosen the design firm of courtyard badge tells a court. Zhu Yan high mountain says, courtyard badge piracy his originality. At present 2 quadrangle of city already put on record.

Stylist says originality is borroweded

May 2004, the Imperial Palace announces through the media such as the network, collect design of courtyard badge label publicly to the society. Up to received be recruited to devise plan in all on September 30, 2004 2788.
　
Evaluate committee through courtyard badge judge first, on January 19, 2005, the Imperial Palace held courtyard badge evaluation to meet in edifice of Beijing overseas Chinese, judge gave 6 to be seleted design program.

Arrived on January 25 on Feburary 15, the Imperial Palace is seleted 6 plan to be put on website of the Imperial Palace to undertake fair show.

All previous classics a year collect with choose fair after showing, this year in May, the Imperial Palace announces courtyard badge collects an activity to not have if really and eventually.

The thing lies between two lunar hind, on July 18, the new courtyard badge that respect of the Imperial Palace announces suddenly to entrust art of Beijing ideal originality to design limited company gives heat.

After the courtyard badge that sees the Imperial Palace is announced finally, design of industry of Anhui industry university is a director Zhu Yan high mountain thinks case of this one party and his contribute arrives from the graph design specification is in likeness more. Zhu Yan high mountain gives out email to show this matter to the Imperial Palace instantly and raise doubt, after this is called twice again.

Tell the Imperial Palace the court

Zhu Yan high mountain says, last year June, after he sees museum of the Imperial Palace recruits the advertisement of courtyard badge, used two weeks of time to complete a design, send oneself design manuscript the Imperial Palace by the requirement.

His work is not 6 work of primary election, he himself also thinks, "The time that designs after all is shorter, lack culture inside information, the likelihood reflects the culture with big gain of the Imperial Palace hard " , did not cherish the hope that be chosen accordingly.

But the courtyard badge that he announces the Imperial Palace and oneself be recruited plan is compared relatively, think both is in the respect such as mutual distance, scale has modelling, stroke to be in similarly truly. The design that Zhu Yan high mountain shows explains, the design specification with badge of courtyard of the Imperial Palace also is put in likeness.

Reply of the Imperial Palace affirms, the be recruited work that got Mr. Zhu and register in book, answer to return case through email hair [link widoczny dla zalogowanych], think to be chosen courtyard badge does not form tort.

Zhu Yan high mountain puts forward in litigant book, the request sentences disuse of your the accused to be chosen courtyard badge, make an apology to accuser through website of the Imperial Palace or other media, compensate for accuser 50 thousand yuan of RMBs.

Zhu Yan high mountain says, he engage in a lawsuit is not for the bonus of tens of thousands of money, get some rights and this v/arc a person's status to design a bound to contend for however, "The Imperial Palace also cannot guest of inn big bully " .

The Imperial Palace says to never reveal plan

Respect of the Imperial Palace thinks, "With ' palace ' the plan that the glyph devises for the foundation, if design a person,create independently only, do not form tort, because ' palace ' the word serves as a Chinese character is public element, there is quite proportional work in drafting plan is with ' palace ' the glyph is fundamental important condition, but undertook is out of shape differently creating [link widoczny dla zalogowanych], each have a characteristic " . At the same time the Imperial Palace denied Zhu Yan high mountain " reveal plan " doubt, say besides fair on the website besides shown 6 designs plan, offer without outward bound, disclose plan of any a be recruited.

After the courtyard badge final version that entrusts company design separately, the Imperial Palace says one's own side is opposite technically what collect to the society is all with " palace " the design program that the word writes for the foundation had review a case in which a death sentence has been passed by a lower court, affirmatory " without one duplicate " .

Representative the Sun Bin of solicitor of office of 100 million fine attorneys of this case thinks [link widoczny dla zalogowanych], the courtyard badge that the Imperial Palace announces and Zhu Yan high mountain be recruited plan is close to very from integral composition of a picture and partial detail [link widoczny dla zalogowanych], the degree of finish that both makes the same score neat, peripheral line in length breadth ratio, bottom and two respects such as the distance between the mouth agree basically. But " copyright law " the expressional form that just protects work, do not protect originality, because the work of duplicate unlike character of this art work is easier comparative. Relevant Information：


[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]